Forum and Google Translate

Since the update, I always get the same error message when I try to translate a topic from another Language & Geographical Communities with Firefox.
And although I have selected “English” as Interface language, it translates this page into German for me.

BTW, with Chrome it works perfectly.

I moved this into its own topic as I think it’s unrelated with the other issue.

I usually don’t use Firefox, but I just tried its translation of a topic and had no issue. Are you using Firefox built-in translation (which it appears to be in beta), or some browser extension?

And what URL does the browser show when it shows that error page?

1 Like

That is the url:
https://community-postcrossing-com.translate.goog/t/translation-in-firefox/864608/t/translation-in-firefox/864608?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=de&_x_tr_hl=de&_x_tr_hist=true

I think it is the built-in translation (???)

Edit:
I have just had various Wikipedia pages in different languages translated into German - they all work perfectly. The Community Guidelines, for example, are also translated without any problems. So it only seems to not work in the forum,

This URL is at a different website (notice the domain is community-postcrossing-com.translate.goog). When I tried the Firefox translation, it translated the page in place, without going to a different website. I’m using

Can you try using this too or do do you know what’s triggering the different behaviour? I’m running Firefox 127.0.2

Yes, that works - and then I can use this kind of translation.
But I’m still wondering why it hasn’t worked since the update the other way.

Can you double check that on Firefox installed add-ons you don’t have something related with google translate?

The reason I ask this is because the trouble may be on said add-on (if it’s the case you have one installed). The URL you were taken too has the bit /t/translation-in-firefox/864608/2 repeated in the URL – removing one of them makes it work. No idea why it’s appearing duplicate.

Yes…

Yes, I removed one and it works :thinking:

Can you check if what you have installed is this:

(don’t install it if you don’t have it)

I think it is not the same add-on as mine, but I have it now deactivated as it works the other way
:arrow_down:

After some more poking, it doesn’t seem to be dependent on a particular add-on or even on Firefox, but on some weird interaction between Google Translate and Discourse.

Steps:

  1. Go directly to https://translate.google.com/
  2. Paste a URL to translate like https://community.postcrossing.com/t/postnl-app/789797
  3. Hit the translation icon/button

The same issue happens. I couldn’t make this happen with other website.

I have reported it to the Discourse team, but it’s unclear where the issue actually is.

2 Likes

Yes, it’s the same.

Thanks for your help and finding another way to translate topics.